Leave those Popes alone!!
Pope
Francis has made a cakewalk into the hearts of even those who are not the least
interested in papacy by his simplistic gestures and stances, so many think. The
“goldlessness” of his pectoral cross, aversion to the bullet proof Pope Mobile,
non-descript pair of shoes and apparels and all the more his exhortation to a
life of simplicity made especially to the prelates have started a storm. Two
posts on my FB newsfeed on this regard had been particularly pestering to me.
1) A snapshot of the humble pair of shoes the Pope was
wearing. It drew questions regarding the validity of that gesture as the Pope
was expected to wear the pair of red shoes symbolizing the blood of the Holy
Martyrs. It even led to the larger question of who is bigger : Pope or
Tradition? Convinced that the colour of the clerical vestments cannot be part
of the Sacred Tradition (understood in the sense of Tradition and Scripture) I
commented wondering what colour would have St.Peter, the first Pope sported.
This tradition is functional and not dogmatic. So the ones waiting for the Pope
to get loose on certain moral and dogmatic rulings that the Church has “vehemently”
upheld ever will be thoroughly disappointed. There can be no dilutions in the
essentials. Be ready for that. Later all those who heap praise on the Pope
shall not swallow their own words and get choked by its sheer volume.
2) Of the many celebrations of the simplicity of Pope
Francis many things are poised on the funnier side. A diptych showed S
t.Francisof Assisi taming the fierce wolf of Gubbio on the one hand and Pope Francis
fondling a service dog on the other. It is quite apparent that there is a world
of differences between the two situations. We are still overstretching.
With no prejudice to the simplicity and sanctity of the
person of Pope Francis certain observations shall be made.
a) Simplicity may be the charism of Pope Francis and he will
surely have a host of other virtues too, which shall not be delectable at
times. They shall not be overlooked.
b) In assuming that Pope Francis is simple, one shall not
presume that no other Pontiffs were equally simple. Perhaps they failed to
register an external gesture to show that they are simple. We cannot make a
relative gradation and evaluation of the lives of Popes as much of their life
is hidden from the public eye and is known only to God.
c) Cardinal Bergoglio was always involved in humanitarian
activities and was noted for his exceptional preference for the poor. I am a
bit wary about the media glare his past accomplishments receive now. It would
amount to saying that all the great works he has done have become very
appreciable now as he has become the Pope. Otherwise nobody is interested.
d) When we celebrate
the simplicity of Pope there can be many perspectives to it. Taking the clerical
status of the Pope as our starting point there is a blunt allusion in it that
the clerics are generally steeped in a life of luxury and impropriety. We are
ill informed to make that comment even about a majority of the clerics. Taking
the authoritative status of Pope as the starting point we are sending a signal
to all centers of power to behave more humanely. Now there is a “third-party”
situation: I-The Simple Pope or his equivalent- and the
flamboyant/wicked/inhuman other and “I” elucidating the example of “Simple Pope”
for the “Wicked Other” to emulate. That is just another way of passing the buck.
You too are an oppressor as much as you are oppressed too. It is easy to
celebrate somebody else’s virtue, especially if it is most endearing and
difficult to cultivate, and it is even easier to celebrate the shortcomings of
others. Let us learn to say “mea
maxima culpa.”
Let
us not allege the Pope of sanctity. He is holy inasmuch as he has responded to
the Divine Will. He will be evermore strengthened to guide the Church through
these difficult times. The Pope himself knows it better than anybody else as is
reflected in his motto “miserando atque eligendo”(shown mercy and
elected). He received greater mercy and grace from the Lord which he shall share
with us all the more. And for our part we shall stop harping on the virtues of
the Popes lest familiarity breeds contempt. Rest assured that human standards
fail miserably when trying to assess the Pope or Petrine ministry.